The Protestant Struggle With Mary

WHY PROTESTANTS STRUGGLE WITH MARY
For Catholics, the Blessed Virgin Mary holds a central place of honor as the Mother of God, the model disciple, and the Queen of Heaven. Yet for many Protestants, devotion to Mary is confusing—or even seen as unbiblical. Why is there such a struggle with Mary among Protestants? The answer lies in history, theology, and misunderstandings.
1. The Reformation’s Break with Tradition
When the Protestant Reformation began in the 16th century, reformers like Martin Luther and John Calvin sought to return to “Scripture alone” (sola scriptura). In the process, many ancient traditions of the Church—including Marian devotion—were set aside. This shift created a suspicion of anything not explicitly outlined in Scripture.
2. Fear of Idolatry
Many Protestants believe Catholic devotion to Mary looks like “worship,” which belongs to God alone. The images, statues, and prayers directed to her are easily misunderstood as giving her the worship due only to God. Catholics, however, make a clear distinction: worship (latria) is given to God alone, while honor (dulia) is given to saints—and the highest honor (hyperdulia) to Mary.
3. The Misunderstanding of Intercession
Catholics ask Mary to “pray for us,” just as one might ask a friend to intercede. But for many Protestants, prayer should only be directed to God. They miss the Catholic understanding that those in Heaven remain connected to us in Christ and can intercede for us before His throne.
4. A Different View of Scripture
Key Catholic beliefs about Mary—such as her Immaculate Conception and Assumption—are not explicitly detailed in the Bible, though they are rooted in Scripture and Tradition. Protestants who follow sola scriptura often reject these teachings because they do not see them spelled out word-for-word.
5. Loss of the Family Dimension of Faith
Catholicism emphasizes that salvation is not just individual but communal. Mary, as spiritual Mother, embodies this family dimension. Protestant traditions, with their focus on individual faith and personal relationship with Christ, often miss the role of spiritual motherhood that Catholics see in Mary.
6. A Growing Reconsideration
Interestingly, some Protestants today are beginning to rediscover Mary—not as a rival to Christ, but as His greatest disciple. Even Martin Luther himself once wrote powerfully about her faith and humility. The more Christians study the early Church, the more they see that honoring Mary was always part of Christian life.
Conclusion
Protestants struggle with Mary because of historical shifts, theological misunderstandings, and fears of idolatry. Yet, Mary always points to her Son. At Fatima, Lourdes, and throughout history, her message has remained the same: “Do whatever He tells you” (John 2:5). Catholics honor her not as a distraction from Jesus, but as the one who leads us more perfectly to Him.
✅ Final Thought: To understand Mary is to understand Christ more deeply. She does not compete with Him—she magnifies Him. Edited from Blessed Virgin Mary facebook group

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Election 2024 - The Guts Are Spilled

The recent presidential election is over – Thank God. But let us look at some of the points involved. First, lets examine our national groundwork: 1. Our government is not a democracy—at least, not just a democracy, alone. Many people have that mistaken idea, promoted long and hard by recent political parties. But when Benjamin Franklin was asked about it he said “Its a republic—if you can keep it.” 2. So whats the difference between a democracy and a republic? A democracy is a government of and by the people, and the US government fits that description. BUT, a republic, by cintrast, is a government of limited powers, and our constitutional framework emphasizes that feature as well. In short we are BOTH – a combination. Which is where our strength lies. 3. Republics, unfortunately, tend to devolve into democracies – and democracy declines into despotism. Why? Because when the people throw off the constraints of limited government, they want always more new government “benefits,”...
Read more

The Assumption of Mary

     The Solemnity of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary is a commemoration celebrated by the Catholic Church, the Eastern Orthodox Church and a few other Christian religions around the world. ----- <  ✠ > -----      This celebration of Mary's Assumption began with 5th century Christians (AD 400's), although evidence points to an earlier observance. But it was, at that time, a remembrance of Mary's life and death, without the Assumption connection. Rather, it bore a sense of Our Lady’s, “Birth Into Heaven,” or, as it was known in the Byzantine tradition, her “Dormition” (falling asleep).       The actual Feast of the Assumption, as we think of it, was first seen within the Church at Rome during the middle of the 7th century.  So while it has obviously been observed by the faithful for a long time, it took roughly 13 centuries for it to be declared doctrine:        On 1, November, 1950, Po...
Read more